American Wife by Curtis Sittenfeld

I was intrigued by the concept of this book: Sittenfeld borrowed the outline of former First Lady Laura Bush's life and built a novel on top of that frame. Laura Bush has always been a more likeable public figure than her husband, and the same proves true for their fictional representations, Alice and Charlie Blackwell. But, somehow, the intimate look at the president makes him more likeable, not less, despite his obvious failings and Alice's disappointment in his actions.

When Laura Bush was a teenager, she was at fault in a car accident in which the other driver was killed. Sittenfeld chose to give this event, and the other driver, central roles in this novel. The other driver is portrayed as Andrew Imhof, and Sittenfeld makes it clear that Alice would have married this boy had he not died. Alice devotes much time to imagining a life in which she never left her small town, in which she never met Charlie Blackwell, and in which she was never complicit in the larger failings of the Blackwell administration. Using the death of Andrew Imhof as a focal point of the novel was an interesting approach. It allowed Sittenfeld to compare the accidental taking of one life with the taking of many lives, via a prolonged and mishandled war. Sittenfeld's ending takes a likeable Alice and makes her complicit in Charlie's war.

Again, I was intrigued by the concept of this book. Unfortunately, Sittenfeld's language is a bit repetitive, and she leans on the same tricks over and over again. How often was I brought back to the present from flashback by a statement such as "In the car, Ella said. . . "? Plus, there were some descriptive paragraphs that were far too wordy, or even totally unnecessary.

I'm glad I read this book, as I am always fascinated by the goings-on within the White House. The story was fascinating, and I was impressed with Sittenfeld's rendering of the beginning of Alice's life--her time as a young girl, with her parents and eccentric grandmother. The imagined details of the life and inner workings of Laura Bush were stellar. Good story, mediocre writing.